The Works of Edgar Allan Poe - Volume 1


google search for The Works of Edgar Allan Poe - Volume 1

Return to Master Book Index.

Page
265 266 267 268 269

Quick Jump
1 90 180 269 359

time enough 'to throw the body into the river before midnight.' This  
assumption, then, amounts precisely to this--that the murder was not  
committed on Sunday at all--and, if we allow L'Etoile to assume this,  
we may permit it any liberties whatever. The paragraph beginning 'It is  
folly to suppose that the murder, etc.,' however it appears as printed  
in L'Etoile, may be imagined to have existed actually thus in the brain  
of its inditer--'It is folly to suppose that the murder, if murder was  
committed on the body, could have been committed soon enough to have  
enabled her murderers to throw the body into the river before midnight;  
it is folly, we say, to suppose all this, and to suppose at the same  
time, (as we are resolved to suppose,) that the body was not thrown  
in until after midnight'--a sentence sufficiently inconsequential in  
itself, but not so utterly preposterous as the one printed.  
"
Were it my purpose," continued Dupin, "merely to make out a case  
against this passage of L'Etoile's argument, I might safely leave it  
where it is. It is not, however, with L'Etoile that we have to do, but  
with the truth. The sentence in question has but one meaning, as it  
stands; and this meaning I have fairly stated: but it is material  
that we go behind the mere words, for an idea which these words have  
obviously intended, and failed to convey. It was the design of the  
journalist to say that, at whatever period of the day or night of Sunday  
this murder was committed, it was improbable that the assassins would  
have ventured to bear the corpse to the river before midnight. And  
herein lies, really, the assumption of which I complain. It is assumed  
267  


Page
265 266 267 268 269

Quick Jump
1 90 180 269 359